So when I last left off in Kazan , expectations were pretty low. The heat was so unbearable I hadn’t gotten around to much of the city and what I had seen of it on my long sweaty stroll down to the Kremlin and back was fairly bleak. It seemed a grey sprawling city full of grandiose Soviet architecture long faded from its glory days, broken dust-filled streets that you have to watch as you walk so that an uneven patch doesn’t catch you by surprise and send you tumbling. I remember a moment on my way back from the Kremlin as I was walking alongside a dried up, trash laden canal, having been in Paris and walked a similar stretch of the Left Bank just the week before, thinking, well, this is exactly what you get for wanting to go to places other people don’t go.
Meanwhile, the battle over my dietary regime was still raging on the homefront. I had won what I thought was defining ground over a dish Aigul called “ovoshi” or “vegetables,” a medley of boiled potatoes, cabbage, sliced hot dogs and a crumbled grayish mystery meat, by falling into bed early and feigning sleep until she went to work the next morning thereby avoiding it for both dinner and breakfast. However, I soon found that whatever ground I claimed one day came back as soon as we squared off again in the form of lengthy harangues that go something like: “you are bad eater, why didn’t you eat all of the cheese in the refrigerator while I was at work, why are you drinking cold water, you shouldn’t drink cold water, I would never drink water cold, the yogurt that you like is repulsive and full of chemicals, I would never eat that yogurt, instead I am now drinking a mug full of cream, why don’t you want to drink a mug full of cream too? there is something wrong with you.”
And I know that I stand accused of harboring a cultural superiority complex. I know this and I dare any anonymous soul out there preaching equality and tolerance among all the world’s peoples to go live in the home of someone from a different culture for a few months. Because it’s all well and good to champion cultural relativity from afar. But it is a completely different proposition when ideas about what is right and good and important for your own health and comfort are being foisted upon you and you are being pressured to change the most basic habits that you know from tried and true experience of your own will make you feel healthy and comfortable. It is realpolitik on a micro individual level. It is true war. I want to behave a certain way. Aigul wants me to behave a completely different way. If I succumb, there is peace. If I resist, there is continued fighting. Real tolerance is only possible with a ridiculously large amount of space between people!
I also know that in resisting rather than submitting I have upended the traditionally defined Tatar roles of guest and host and that the same would be true in any Russian, Georgian, Albanian, Serbian or Tajik home I’ve ever visited. In doing so, I am being supremely rude. I know this. And yet I can’t seem to just give myself, particularly my body, over completely. Maybe I am too old to be doing this. Maybe teenagers and college kids go abroad and stay with host families while adult professionals don’t, not because of the differential in resources and opportunities, but because of the differential in levels of flexibility. The weird thing is that this is all making me question fundamentals about who and what I am. Because if you’d asked me two weeks ago, I would have self-reported that I am a very flexible person who is interested in and sensitive to other cultures and that is exactly my value added in going into the field to study comparative politics. I think potentially I am still that person but I am just reporting much of the day-to-day conflict that otherwise goes unreported. Though, I don’t know. Did Jim Scott and Libby Wood feign sleep to avoid the version of “ovoshi” they were served or did they lap it up like good political anthropologists? Is this strife a way of highlighting where the differences between cultural assumptions lie and therefore productive and positive? Or have I really just become the insensitive American who goes abroad and snubs local ways of life? (I did have that moment of deep-seated craving for McDonald’s after all!) Is this just the inevitable chafing of a square unit from one system trying to insert itself into a universe of circle units? And will it abate as my edges get worn down or continue chafing until I head home at the end of the year? I suppose only time will reveal how much of a self-interested asshole I have actually become.
Such was life in Tatarstan, somewhat fractious and seemingly grey, until a fortuitous moment in the basement level computer room of Kazan State University . I had made significant progress with the university bureaucracy. They had assigned me an instructor and after a compromise I probably shouldn’t put in writing lest grant officers catch wind of the blog, we agreed that I would have 30 “academic” hours of one-on-one Russian classes with her per week. I’d met the instructor for the first time that morning and liked her very much, and she had dismissed me for the day so that she could work on planning my curriculum.
Internet-starved I was in the midst of returning emails when two girls chattering in English and smacking gum walked in. My first response was to ignore them, the hackles rising up along my shoulders at the sound of their American accents. And I think this is exactly why I became so interested in neuroscience, as a potential albeit after deeper consideration as of yet completely impractical way, of solving the world’s problems. There is the part of my brain that instinctively hunches and narrows my eyes in response to outsiders. It comes on first and starts the stream of conscious narrative in my head moving in an ugly direction, reacting negatively to every innocuous comment out of their mouths, and actually physically making my posture tense, my shoulders hunched and closed. And then, thankfully, there is another part of my brain that detects this behavior and rejects and censures it. This part interjects into the stream of conscious narrative like a parent or a boss and starts berating the narrator. “Stop this foul behavior. You are being a jerk. Put your shoulders down, take a deep breath and talk to these girls.” There is resistance from the bratty narrator who doesn’t want anything to do with these outsiders, but eventually it concedes that the other part is right and we will all, in this organism that is Leslie, be made better off by positive social interaction.
I turned in my seat and flashed a smile at the girls, “Hey, are you guys American?”
The one girl, a solidly built brunette looked over her shoulder at me, “No, we’re Russians who just speak really good English,” she scoffed. Her friend, a lither blonde, chortled as she glanced over her shoulder to eye me up.
And I think a similar process of resisting interaction with an outsider and then correcting for better social graces must have been occurring in the neural pathways of these girls’ brains as well because the brunette then made eye contact and smiled more avidly saying, “I mean, no, of course we’re American. Did you just get here?”
“Yeah, I just got here yesterday. Have you guys been here for awhile?” I asked.
“Yeah, we’ve been here for the whole summer” the blonde informed me, now turning to face me. “This is our last day. We’re actually leaving tomorrow.”
“Yeah. We were on the Blah-Blah-Blah scholars program,” the brunette took up from her friend at blazing conversational speed, “which is so awesome because it’s funded by the State Department and we get a stipend and don’t have to pay for anything. And if we want, we can apply for the same program next year to come back for a whole year and I’m totally going to do that because I totally love it here. I mean I’m from Manhattan so it’s not like I’m from the middle of nowhere and this place is *really* cool. What program are you on?”
The “I’m on a very elite program, tell me which program you are on so that I can rank myself relative to you” question really irked me but I pressed on with the conversation, intentionally not dropping any names. “I’m on my own actually. I’m here to work on my Russian and then do research in the region for my dissertation.”
“What’s a dissertation?” the brunette asked, her eyes squinting, “I mean, I think I know what it is, but I’m not totally sure.”
“Oh, no, of course,” I apologized because the realization had just hit me like a brick in the face—these were *high school* girls. That was what was so strange and obnoxious about them! It wasn’t their fault. “I’m doing a PhD. You write a dissertation to get a PhD.”
And once we had broken the ice, and the girls had placed me as a non-threatening perhaps even interesting entity somewhere in their high school social hierarchy, all jousting ceased and the floodgates of information opened, both of them talking over each other to tell me *everything* that I needed to know about Kazan.
“You have to go to the Meat House on Baumana street , everything there is really good.” “And the Blini House too, right nearby on Baumana, has the best ice cream and the best lemonade. I mean it’s not like real lemonade but it’s the closest you can get and it’s really good.” “And the ice cream on the street is really good too and it’s really cheap. Gelato is more expensive, but that’s true anywhere.” “And if you go to the beach near the city, don’t put your head underwater because the water is really dirty. But if you go an hour out it’s ok cause the water is cleaner.” “Oh and you have to go to Koltso, the mall, you’ll see it, it’s the big building at the start of Baumana street with a big ring in front.” “Yeah, they have super cheap movies and you have to get the sladkiy (sweet) popcorn cause it’s amazing.”
And any lingering worry that the next generation is growing up too fast that I might have acquired watching teenagers drink scotch and sleep with call girls on Gossip Girl (shhhh, terrible habit) was completely alleviated. I found the fact that these girls did not mention a single bar but gave me explicit instructions on where to find the best lemonade in the city completely endearing.
“So where is Baumana street exactly?” I asked.
“Oh my God, you haven’t been on Baumana street yet,” the blonde’s jaw dropped.
“Evvvvverything’s on Baumana Street ” the brunette shook her head.
And after the girls departed, I braved the heat, which had at least abated into the 90s, to check out this Baumana street of which they spoke. I was reading from the instructions they had given me worried that I might not find it. “Turn right outside of the university, then right again. Walk down the hill and you’ll see a huge red brick onion-domed building.” And looking up that’s exactly what I saw. This oddly gothic but incredibly welcoming almost playful building soaring way up in the air marked the start of Baumana street .
Onion-Domed Red Brick Building
a.k.a. the Chapel of the Church of the Epiphany
With the Actual Church of the Epiphany Hiding Behind It
I turned the corner and it was as if I had suddenly walked into a whole new Kazan . The city went from a grey post-Soviet wasteland to a wildly colored seaside town with quirky character and erratic charm. Walking down the brick paved pedestrian boulevard of Baumana street literally and quite surreally felt like walking down a boardwalk. There was carnival music playing loudly out of speakers spaced along the street. There were games to play, darts to throw, pictures to be taken with doves a handler put on your shoulders, cotton candy and ice cream and bubble gum to buy. There were fountains and carriages, both bronzed as statues and horse-drawn walking down the street. There were artists painting caricatures and serious portraits and little tattoo booths where pierced, sullen teenagers were waiting to exploit a moment of bad decision-making and take needles to your arm.
Fairytale Kazan
Note Girl with Doves in the Foreground
Maybe Explains Why My Host Mother has so Many Stuffed Animals around the House??
Seaside Town without a Sea (Though Perhaps the River Counts for Landlocked Locals)
Strangely Somewhat Reminiscent of both Tallinn and Belgrade
Bubble Gum!
Spitting Frog Fountains
Mr. Souvenir
And both sides of the street were overflowing with cafes and restaurants each more creatively themed than the next--from the Che decorated Cuba Libre to the traditional old tea house, from the Meat House to the Blini House-- it all looked like so much fun.
Cute Tea House
And by the time I made it down to the spectacle that is the Koltso shopping mall at the very end of Baumana street, my previously calculated projections for how the next three months would go were shattered as it now seemed anything might be possible in this brave new Kazan .
Kazan or Abu Dhabi??
A Brave New Kazan, Indeed!










